Oil Train Legislation in Oregon

Friends supports strong oil train emergency response legislation

Oil Train Legislation in Oregon
The fiery aftermath of the oil train derailment at Mosier, OR, June 3, 2016. (photographer: Michael McKeag)

Oregon communities continue to be at risk due to unsafe crude oil trains and the lack of emergency response preparation. The threat was illustrated in June 2016 when an oil train in Mosier, OR derailed and spilled oil that leaked into the Columbia River, causing a large fire near homes and an elementary school.

Several oil-emergency response bills are being considered in 2019 Legislative Session.

Attend the Next Oil Train Bill Hearing

Friends of the Columbia Gorge, Stand Up to Oil Coalition, Oregon Conservation Network, Columbia Riverkeeper, Sierra Club and Oregon Physicians for Social Responsibility are supporting legislation in the Oregon Legislature that would help protect Oregon from crude oil train derailments and oil spills. Transporting oil by rail is inherently unsafe. As long as it continues, we must prepare for the next derailment and spill.

Several bills addressing oil train emergency response have been introduced. These bills should require:
  • Approval of contingency plans and training for oil train-related spills;
  • Fees on railroads to improve oil spill response and establish funding for emergency preparedness;
  • Adequate insurance for railroads to cover true worst-case oil train derailments and oil spills; and
  • 24-hour notice for oil trains
S.B. 99 and its companion in the House, HB 2858, include all of these common-sense steps to address oil train emergency preparation and response. Three other oil train bills, including HB 2064, HB 2209 and SB 229, lack one or more of the components above and would need to be amended to better protect Oregon’s communities and waterways from oil spills and fires.

Friends' concerns about the three additional oil train bills:


HB 2064: This bill was submitted at the request of Governor Kate Brown on behalf of the Department of Environmental Quality. It is a good bill for the most part, but needs amendments. It defines "worst case spill" as only up to 15% of an oil train's capacity. It also lacks 24-hour notification requirements for incoming oil trains. Friends would support this bill if it is amended to include notification and changed the definition of worst-case spill to include 100% of the typical oil train's capacity, or 3 million gallons, to match HB 2858.

HB 2209: This bill is in the House Committee On Veterans and Emergency Preparedness. It is supported by the railroads and is significantly weaker than HB 2858. The bill should be amended to mirror HB 2858.

SB 229: Includes a pilot project for trainings on oil spill and hazardous material response, communication between emergency responders and industry, and a study of oil spill plans. The bill is lacking the essential elements included in HB 2858 and SB 99.
 

Why Oil Train Legislation Is Needed


Unsafe Rail Cars: Since 2012, explosive Bakken crude oil is being transported by rail at high speeds through the Columbia River Gorge National Scenic Area, the Deschutes River Canyon, and many communities throughout Oregon. Oil is transported through Oregon to refineries in California and Washington, with no direct benefit to Oregon’s economy. Explosive Bakken oil is transported in unsafe rail cars that puncture at speeds as low as 14 mph, leading to oil fires and explosions. New federal safety standards for rail cars only slightly improve impact resistance. Unit trains of oil carry up to 120 oil tank cars containing over 3 million gallons of volatile Bakken Crude oil or tar sands oil. These pipelines on rails endanger communities and waterways along major rail routes through Oregon, risking severe damage to public safety, drinking water, and Columbia River salmon habitat.
 
A unit oil train travels on BNSF rail line parallel to WA State Route 14. (photographer: Randa Cleaves)
Derailments and Explosions: In the past five years, several oil train derailments, explosions and fires in North America have resulted in 47 deaths, the evacuation of thousands of people, millions of gallons of oil spilled into waterways and billions of dollars of property damage and environmental destruction. Our fears were realized in 2016 when an oil train derailed in the small Gorge town of Mosier, catching fire and spilling 42,000 gallons of oil. Mosier residents were spared only because it was a rare windless day, thus preventing the fire from spreading into the community. The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) determined that Union Pacific Railroad’s negligence caused the derailment. FRA statistics show Union Pacific has more derailments and accidents caused by equipment failures compared to industry average. We continue our work to reduce the threats of oil-by-rail in the hope of preventing any future such disasters.


Crude oil export ban lifted in 2015: For 35 years, the U.S. ensured energy independence by prohibiting export of U.S. crude oil. In 2015, Congress lifted the U.S. crude oil export ban, thus creating the likelihood of new export terminals on the West Coast. As soon as the price of oil rebounds, residents of the Northwest can expect to see more oil train traffic.

Trump administration repeals oil train safety requirement: Recently, the Trump administration repealed the 2015 requirement for oil trains to use electronically controlled pneumatic (ECP) brakes by 2021, which would have improved the safety of oil trains and likely reduced the severity of derailments and resulting oil spills. Safety advocates, transportation union leaders and lawmakers oppose the repeal of the ECP brake rule. Several Governors, including Governor Kate Brown, criticized the repeal and called on federal policy makers to put in place the strongest rail safety measures. (Source: Governors Brown and Inslee Joint Media Release, Dec. 8, 2017)

Is Oregon ready?: Oregon has the weakest laws on the west coast related to oil trains and oil terminals. In the Mosier derailment, oil spill and fire, Oregon had to rely heavily on the Washington Department of Ecology for assistance. Both California and Washington have passed laws similar to those proposed in the 2019 session in Oregon. Notably, these new laws have not been preempted by federal railroad laws.
 

Contacts for more information 



View a PDF of this page
+ Read More


Get Involved

Friends’ conservation work is driven by members, volunteers, and activists. There are many ways to join our community of Gorge enthusiasts. Here are some ways to get started: